The ice units dont work very well since the surface area of the ice is relatively small and the ice melts quickly.

A swamp cooler works by the heat of vaporization of water...it takes roughly 8700 BTUs to vaporize one gallon of water. The rate of evaporation is related to the surface area of the evaporator pad, the water temperature, the air humidity, and the air flow over the pad. As a reference, one ton of airconditioning is about 12,000 BTU/HR or about 3.5KW. Note that the one ton of air conditioning is a time-based figure while the swamp cooler reference is not time based....but IF you evaporated about 1 1/2 gallons per hour, then you would have about the equivalent of one ton of airconditioning in your swamp.

The smaller, car window units are limited to the pad size so their volume evaporated is relatively small....but better than nothing.

As a side note, the desert water cooler bags seen hanging on the front of cars in the old days and the blanket covered canteens the cowboys had worked the same way...the exterior was moistened and the air evaporation pulled heat away from the container. In fact, in the old days, people slept outside in the SouthWest and hung water soaked sheets over a line and slept down wind from them for the cooling effect....the first swamp coolers.

mike in tucson